Rethinking Defensiveness: A Path to Mutual Understanding

How many times have you heard people weaponize being “defensive”? “You’re being defensive!” We accuse each other of this as if we are pointing out a moral failure or a flaw. The truth is if someone is indeed protecting themselves it’s a sign that their mind and nervous system ARE WORKING PROPERLY given what they assume about the moment. Meaning that we are supposed to be able to protect ourselves from threat when we perceive it. Our nervous systems are designed to go between open and closed all the time. It would not help you survive if you were in a protective mode all the time and equally it would not serve survival if you were open all the time. You need to be able to move dynamically between these modes.

The next time you sense someone is in a defensive mode TAKE STOCK OF YOURSELF and notice if it bothers you. If so, get curious. What’s going on right now? What’s my emotional state, how am I impacting them? What are they going through and how does it make sense? How am I feeling and what do I need right now? Is that need available here or do I need to make a change?

The point is defensiveness is not bad the real issue is relating mutually. We fail to own our personal impact usually because we are insecure. Recognizing how we are contributing to a relational moment is not admitting some kind of objective failure or guilt or shame it’s simply recognizing WHAT might be happening not who is right and who is wrong. That kind of black and white, win or lose thinking is indicative of being in an insecure state that might let you know that a change is needed to feel less threatened again so you can return to reflective thinking.