Why Couples Get Stuck (And How Therapy Helps You Move Again)

Many couples come to counseling because they feel stuck in the same arguments, shut-downs, or misunderstandings. Most don’t know why it keeps happening, especially when both partners say they love each other and want things to improve. It can feel confusing and discouraging.

Couples counseling can help, not by assigning blame, but by helping you understand the patterns underneath the conflict.

Patterns Are Like Loops

Most couples don’t just have “fights.” They have loops—the same dance repeated with new content. One partner reaches out, the other pulls away. One pushes for clarity, the other protects by shutting down. One gets louder, one gets quiet. The topic changes, but the loop stays the same.

These loops form because each partner is trying to protect something important—usually a longing or a vulnerability they stopped showing a long time ago.

It’s Not Just Communication. It’s What Communication Is Protecting

Communication skills matter, but skills alone often don’t solve the deeper issue. Many couples already know how to communicate—they just don’t know how to stay connected when they feel misunderstood, criticized, or afraid.

That requires understanding what’s happening inside the relationship space between partners. Therapists call this the intersubjective field, but practically it means:

“What is it like to be me with you, and what is it like to be you with me, especially when we are stressed?”

That space between partners is where relationships actually get repaired.

Improvisation: The Opposite of Keeping Score

When conflict loops form, couples often start keeping score: who apologized last, who’s trying more, who should change first. Scorekeeping feels organized, but it makes relationships rigid.

In couples counseling, we help partners learn something closer to improvisation. Instead of sticking to defensive scripts (“here we go again,” “I already know how this ends”), partners learn how to stay responsive and curious in the moment.

Improvisation creates openings. Openings create repair. Repair builds real trust.

Why This Approach Works

This style of couples therapy focuses on:

• recognizing your shared pattern
• understanding how each of you protects yourselves
• identifying the longings underneath conflict
• creating space for new emotional experiences
• practicing repair in real time

When couples experience successful repair—not perfection, but repair—their nervous systems begin to trust each other again. Arguments become less about survival and more about connection.

You Don’t Have to Stay Stuck

If you and your partner feel trapped in a loop, it doesn’t mean your relationship is broken. It means the two of you are due for a new way of relating—one that allows both partners to feel seen, understood, and safe enough to show what they actually feel.

At Analog Counseling in Overland Park, we help couples across the Kansas City metro learn how to repair, reconnect, and build new relational patterns. In-person and telehealth options are available.

FAQ: Couples Counseling

Why do couples get stuck in the same arguments?
Most couples repeat patterns because each partner is protecting a deeper longing or vulnerability. Therapy helps reveal and repair the loop.

Is couples counseling just communication skills?
Communication skills help, but lasting change comes from understanding the emotional patterns underneath conflict—not just the words.

How long does couples counseling take?
Most couples attend between a couple of months to a year or two of weekly sessions depending on goals, pace, and level of conflict.

Is it too late for counseling if we’re considering separation?
Not necessarily. Many couples wait until things feel urgent before seeking help, and repair is still possible.

Do you offer in-person or telehealth sessions?
Yes. We serve the Kansas City metro through in-person sessions in Overland Park and secure telehealth for Missouri and Kansas residents.

Navigating Conflict Beyond Trigger Warnings

Conflict is challenging. It becomes even more difficult when a trauma response is triggered. Imagine treating a minor issue like a major crisis—a "five-dollar problem" escalating to a "five-hundred-dollar problem." This often happens unconsciously, making it feel like a rational reaction. So, how can we address a problem that we can't directly perceive? Here are three steps to help navigate this issue:

Awareness

Trauma responses encompass physical, mental, emotional, and visceral layers. Although these responses are typically unconscious, we can bring them into our awareness. Increasing awareness reduces dissociation, allowing us to detect our feelings, thoughts, actions, and sensations when triggered. To practice this, think about a situation where past pain caused you to overreact in the present. Stay grounded in the present while asking yourself:

• What do I think when I'm triggered?

• What do I feel emotionally when I'm triggered?

• What do I do (both verbally and physically) when I'm triggered?

• What do I sense viscerally when I'm triggered?

Slow Down

Slowing down involves observing without acting. Notice your answers to the above questions, but resist the urge to act on them. This practice, known as mindfulness, creates a gap between your reaction and your actions. To activate your parasympathetic nervous system (the calming "brake pedal"), try the following techniques:

• Take a physiological sigh (two breaths in, one breath out)

• Drink some water

• Spend time in nature or with a beloved pet

• Practice orienting (check out our video on this technique)

• Reflective listening (repeat back what the other person said until they confirm you understood correctly)

Reflect

Reflection involves thinking about your thoughts, feelings, sensations, and desires. Assess whether your desires align with the situation and your values. Often, you'll need to find a compromise between your immediate impulses and your core values to achieve a beneficial outcome.

Decide and Act

Once you've reflected, consciously decide on the best course of action. Now, you're ready to address the situation appropriately, treating a five-dollar problem like a five-dollar problem.

By following these steps, you can navigate conflicts more effectively, reducing the impact of unconscious trauma responses and fostering healthier interactions.